Home / City cars
Reliability ranking
The most reliable city cars
53 city cars ranked on 3,724,964 inspections in the Netherlands and the UK · updated 13 November 2026
City cars differ a lot. The best scores 8.8 out of 10 and the worst 2.8. A typical one scores 5.6.
If reliability matters most, the Toyota iQ, Opel Karl Rocks and Suzuki Celerio are the safest bets.
Our top three Most reliable
8.8likely 8.0 to 9.3
Technical faults turn up 46% less often than on the average car of the same age and fuel. Based on 18,962 cars registered 2009 to 2014.
Is the Toyota iQ reliable?
2 8.7 Technical faults turn up 45% less often than on the average car of the same age and fuel. Based on 6,265 cars registered 2017 to 2019.
Is the Opel Karl Rocks reliable? 3 7.8 Technical faults turn up 30% less often than on the average car of the same age and fuel. Based on 38,677 cars registered 2015 to 2020.
Is the Suzuki Celerio reliable?
The full ranking Every city car with at least 1,000 cars inspected. Tap a car for its likely range, its years and the fault to watch for.
All fuels Petrol Hybrid Electric Diesel LPG
Score Most cars A to Z
1 Toyota iQ Better than most city cars 18,962 cars 8.8
Likely 8.0 to 9.3 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2009 to 2014
8.7 20098.8 20108.9 20118.8 20128.9 20139.3 2014
Watch for: Anti-roll bar link dust cover: lets dirt in, found 88% more often than on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Toyota iQ reliable?
2 Opel Karl Rocks Better than most city cars 6,265 cars 8.7
Likely 7.4 to 9.4 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2017 to 2019
8.5 20179.2 20186.9 2019
Watch for: Exhaust leaking / unsafe outlet, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Opel Karl Rocks reliable?
3 Suzuki Celerio Better than most city cars 38,677 cars 7.8
Likely 6.8 to 8.6 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2015 to 2020
8.5 20158.0 20167.4 20177.5 20185.5 20194.8 2020
Watch for: Brake pipe: excessively corroded, found 9× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Suzuki Celerio reliable?
4 Toyota Aygo X Better than most city cars 17,810 cars 7.6
Likely 6.1 to 8.7 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2022 to 2023
7.7 20225.3 2023
Watch for: Wheel bearing worn (noise or play), found 7× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Toyota Aygo X reliable?
5 Škoda Citigo Better than most city cars 69,078 cars 7.0
Likely 5.7 to 8.0 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Electric · registered 2012 to 2021
7.4 20127.3 20137.5 20147.0 20156.4 20166.7 20177.0 20186.3 20195.5 2020
Watch for: Airbag / seatbelt warning light on, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Škoda Citigo reliable?
6 Volkswagen up! Better than most city cars 236,609 cars 7.0
Likely 5.7 to 8.0 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Electric, LPG · registered 2011 to 2023
5.5 20117.0 20127.2 20137.4 20147.1 20156.1 20167.2 20177.5 20186.6 20196.1 20205.3 20216.5 2022
Watch for: Airbag / seatbelt warning light on, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Volkswagen up! reliable?
7 Smart EQ Probably better than most city cars 4,646 cars 6.9
Likely 3.8 to 8.9 Yellow line: typical city car
Electric · registered 2018 to 2022
4.1 20197.8 20209.4 20217.5 2022
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Smart EQ reliable?
8 Perodua Myvi Probably better than most city cars 1,664 cars 6.8
Likely 4.9 to 8.3 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2007 to 2013
6.5 2010
Watch for: Engine warning light: on or not working, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Perodua Myvi reliable?
9 Fiat 500E About average for a city car 1,111 cars 6.8
Likely 3.3 to 9.0 Yellow line: typical city car
Electric · registered 2014 to 2017
6.5 20147.5 2016
Watch for: Brake disc badly corroded, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Fiat 500E reliable?
10 SEAT Mii Probably better than most city cars 37,103 cars 6.7
Likely 5.3 to 7.8 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Electric · registered 2012 to 2021
6.8 20126.3 20137.3 20147.1 20156.5 20166.4 20177.1 20185.8 20198.0 20205.4 2021
Watch for: Airbag / seatbelt warning light on, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the SEAT Mii reliable?
11 Toyota Aygo Probably better than most city cars 396,116 cars 6.5
Likely 5.3 to 7.6 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2005 to 2022
6.5 20116.9 20127.0 20136.9 20147.6 20157.8 20167.6 20178.1 20187.2 20195.4 20204.9 20214.2 2022
Watch for: Wheel bearing worn (noise or play), found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Toyota Aygo reliable?
12 Opel Karl Probably better than most city cars 66,799 cars 6.4
Likely 5.1 to 7.5 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2015 to 2019
6.9 20156.2 20166.1 20177.0 20185.5 2019
Watch for: Anti-roll bar link dust cover: lets dirt in, found 8× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Opel Karl reliable?
13 Daihatsu Sirion Probably better than most city cars 17,416 cars 6.3
Likely 5.0 to 7.5 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 1999 to 2011
5.9 20056.6 20066.5 20076.6 20086.3 20096.4 2010
Watch for: Suspension arm ball joint: excessively worn, found 5× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Daihatsu Sirion reliable?
14 Peugeot 108 Probably better than most city cars 128,315 cars 6.3
Likely 5.0 to 7.5 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2014 to 2022
5.9 20146.6 20156.9 20166.8 20176.9 20185.8 20193.6 20203.1 20212.4 2022
Watch for: Wheel bearing worn (noise or play), found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Peugeot 108 reliable?
15 Nissan Pixo Probably better than most city cars 21,032 cars 6.3
Likely 5.0 to 7.4 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2009 to 2013
6.4 20096.3 20106.5 20115.6 20126.0 2013
Watch for: Brake pipe: excessively corroded, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Nissan Pixo reliable?
16 Smart Fortwo Probably better than most city cars 62,233 cars 6.3
Likely 5.0 to 7.4 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Electric, Diesel · registered 2001 to 2019
6.5 20086.8 20096.3 20106.6 20116.3 20125.5 20136.1 20145.8 20156.5 20167.0 20179.0 20186.8 2019
Watch for: Engine warning light: on or not working, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Smart Fortwo reliable?
17 Citroën 2CV About average for a city car 2,340 cars 6.3
Likely 4.3 to 7.9 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 1985 to 1990
7.3 19865.7 19877.0 19886.4 1989
Watch for: Exhaust emissions: carbon monoxide too high, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Citroën 2CV reliable?
18 Morris Minor About average for a city car 1,837 cars 6.2
Likely 4.3 to 7.9 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 1966 to 1971
Watch for: Footbrake: uneven across an axle, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Morris Minor reliable?
19 Citroën C1 Probably better than most city cars 261,698 cars 6.2
Likely 5.0 to 7.4 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2005 to 2022
6.6 20116.9 20126.9 20137.0 20146.8 20156.3 20166.5 20177.4 20185.8 20194.1 20202.9 20212.9 2022
Watch for: Wheel bearing: rough when rotated, found 6× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Citroën C1 reliable?
20 Peugeot 107 Probably better than most city cars 197,163 cars 6.2
Likely 4.9 to 7.3 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2005 to 2014
5.0 20055.4 20065.3 20075.2 20085.6 20096.4 20106.5 20116.9 20127.1 20137.3 2014
Watch for: Exhaust leaking / unsafe outlet, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Peugeot 107 reliable?
21 Suzuki Ignis About average for a city car 51,109 cars 6.1
Likely 4.7 to 7.4 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Hybrid · registered 2001 to 2023
6.1 20026.1 20036.3 20045.9 20056.2 20066.3 20075.8 20176.1 20188.2 20199.4 20209.4 20219.4 2022
Watch for: Coil spring: broken, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Suzuki Ignis reliable?
22 Mitsubishi Space About average for a city car 40,208 cars 6.1
Likely 4.8 to 7.3 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 1999 to 2022
4.0 20043.8 20056.7 20136.8 20147.4 20158.1 20167.3 20176.9 20185.3 20193.6 20203.1 20211.6 2022
Watch for: Ball joint boot damaged, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Mitsubishi Space reliable?
23 Suzuki Wagon R About average for a city car 9,158 cars 6.0
Likely 4.4 to 7.4 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2000 to 2006
4.9 20004.8 20015.8 20026.3 20037.0 20046.9 20057.1 2006
Watch for: Wheel bearing worn (noise or play), found 91% more often than on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Suzuki Wagon R reliable?
24 Suzuki Alto About average for a city car 87,348 cars 6.0
Likely 4.7 to 7.2 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 1998 to 2015
5.0 20024.0 20033.7 20043.4 20053.2 20066.5 20096.5 20106.3 20116.1 20126.3 20135.8 20145.5 2015
Watch for: Wheel bearing worn (noise or play), found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Suzuki Alto reliable?
25 Subaru Justy About average for a city car 1,815 cars 5.9
Likely 4.4 to 7.3 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2007 to 2010
6.1 20086.5 20095.2 2010
Watch for: Suspension arm ball joint: excessively worn, found 5× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Subaru Justy reliable?
26 Peugeot 1007 About average for a city car 3,202 cars 5.7
Likely 4.3 to 7.0 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2005 to 2008
5.5 20055.6 20066.2 2007
Watch for: Airbag / seatbelt warning light on, found 68% more often than on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Peugeot 1007 reliable?
27 Suzuki Wagon About average for a city car 7,604 cars 5.6
Likely 4.2 to 6.9 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2000 to 2008
5.1 20014.8 20025.6 20035.9 20046.0 20055.9 20066.5 2007
Watch for: Suspension arm ball joint: excessively worn, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Suzuki Wagon reliable?
28 Daihatsu Cuore About average for a city car 13,552 cars 5.4
Likely 3.9 to 6.9 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 1999 to 2011
4.8 20023.8 20034.4 20044.4 20054.7 20064.7 20076.1 20086.9 20097.4 20107.6 2011
Watch for: Rust damage, main member, found 34× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Daihatsu Cuore reliable?
29 Hyundai Atos About average for a city car 14,576 cars 5.4
Likely 4.0 to 6.6 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 1999 to 2008
3.3 20003.7 20014.2 20024.9 20036.2 20045.8 20055.3 20065.7 20076.7 2008
Watch for: Suspension mounting area: excessively corroded, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Hyundai Atos reliable?
30 Rover Mini About average for a city car 10,505 cars 5.4
Likely 3.7 to 6.9 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 1986 to 2001
5.5 19904.7 19914.6 19925.4 19935.4 19945.3 19954.2 19965.5 19975.1 19985.5 19995.2 20007.1 2001
Watch for: Steering rack: gaiter missing or split, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Rover Mini reliable?
31 Smart Forfour About average for a city car 26,691 cars 5.3
Likely 3.9 to 6.6 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Electric · registered 2004 to 2019
6.4 20046.8 20056.6 20064.8 20153.6 20164.8 20175.1 20185.1 2019
Watch for: Exhaust emissions: lambda reading out of range, found 5× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Smart Forfour reliable?
32 Volkswagen Lupo About average for a city car 8,933 cars 5.3
Likely 4.0 to 6.5 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1999 to 2005
4.2 19994.7 20005.3 20015.3 20025.2 20035.7 20045.9 2005
Watch for: Excessive fluid leak (oil, coolant etc.), found 46% more often than on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Volkswagen Lupo reliable?
33 Opel Agila About average for a city car 70,978 cars 5.1
Likely 3.8 to 6.4 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2000 to 2015
6.3 20046.4 20056.4 20067.2 20074.5 20084.6 20094.5 20104.6 20115.2 20125.8 20135.5 20146.6 2015
Watch for: Suspension arm ball joint: excessively worn, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Opel Agila reliable?
34 Kia Picanto About average for a city car 309,877 cars 5.1
Likely 3.8 to 6.4 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2004 to 2023
5.6 20126.2 20136.1 20145.9 20155.3 20165.7 20177.6 20186.4 20196.2 20206.7 20216.5 20224.0 2023
Watch for: Handbrake: too weak, found 5× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Kia Picanto reliable?
35 Suzuki Splash About average for a city car 30,028 cars 5.1
Likely 3.8 to 6.3 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2008 to 2015
4.9 20084.6 20094.6 20104.4 20115.7 20126.2 20136.0 20147.3 2015
Watch for: Shock absorber: serious fluid leak, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Suzuki Splash reliable?
36 Hyundai i10 About average for a city car 319,022 cars 5.0
Likely 3.7 to 6.3 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2008 to 2023
5.0 20124.2 20134.6 20145.4 20155.7 20164.9 20173.9 20182.4 20193.9 20200.8 20210.7 20225.0 2023
Watch for: Brake disc badly corroded, found 5× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Hyundai i10 reliable?
37 Volkswagen Fox About average for a city car 36,316 cars 5.0
Likely 3.7 to 6.3 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2005 to 2011
5.2 20055.5 20065.3 20074.9 20084.5 20094.4 20104.4 2011
Watch for: Driveshaft boot damaged, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Volkswagen Fox reliable?
38 SEAT Arosa Probably worse than most city cars 4,523 cars 5.0
Likely 3.6 to 6.3 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 1998 to 2005
4.8 19995.0 20005.2 20014.8 20025.3 20035.2 2004
Watch for: Excessive fluid leak (oil, coolant etc.), found 50% more often than on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the SEAT Arosa reliable?
39 Austin Mini About average for a city car 2,647 cars 4.9
Likely 3.1 to 6.8 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 1985 to 1989
5.2 19874.8 19884.3 1989
Watch for: Exhaust emissions: carbon monoxide too high, found 7× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Austin Mini reliable?
40 Chevrolet Spark Probably worse than most city cars 27,758 cars 4.9
Likely 3.5 to 6.2 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, LPG · registered 2010 to 2014
5.0 20105.0 20115.0 20124.4 20134.0 2014
Watch for: Brake pipe: excessively corroded, found 9× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Chevrolet Spark reliable?
41 Fiat Panda Probably worse than most city cars 155,086 cars 4.8
Likely 3.5 to 6.1 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel, LPG · registered 2002 to 2022
4.7 20115.1 20124.9 20134.6 20143.9 20153.7 20163.0 20173.1 20182.1 20191.5 20201.0 20210.7 2022
Watch for: Exhaust leaking / unsafe outlet, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Fiat Panda reliable?
42 Ford Ka Probably worse than most city cars 208,610 cars 4.6
Likely 3.4 to 5.9 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2000 to 2019
3.8 20084.4 20094.6 20105.0 20115.0 20124.7 20134.1 20143.5 20153.3 20167.1 20174.4 20186.3 2019
Watch for: Exhaust leaking / unsafe outlet, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Ford Ka reliable?
43 Fiat Abarth Probably worse than most city cars 30,187 cars 4.6
Likely 3.3 to 6.1 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2009 to 2022
5.7 20115.4 20124.8 20135.4 20144.6 20154.5 20164.1 20174.3 20184.0 20193.3 20204.5 20213.0 2022
Watch for: Wheel bearing worn (noise or play), found 4× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Fiat Abarth reliable?
44 Fiat 500 Probably worse than most city cars 455,038 cars 4.4
Likely 3.1 to 5.7 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Hybrid, Electric, Diesel · registered 2007 to 2023
4.8 20124.9 20134.0 20143.3 20152.7 20163.1 20173.4 20182.1 20194.0 20204.4 20215.1 20228.5 2023
Watch for: Suspension arm bushes: excessively worn, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Fiat 500 reliable?
45 Peugeot 106 Probably worse than most city cars 6,390 cars 4.4
Likely 3.1 to 5.7 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1994 to 2003
3.9 19974.6 19983.6 19993.5 20004.3 20014.3 20025.2 2003
Watch for: Brake imbalance on one axle, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Peugeot 106 reliable?
46 Daihatsu Charade Probably worse than most city cars 1,224 cars 4.3
Likely 2.8 to 6.0 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2003 to 2006
Watch for: Suspension arm ball joint: excessively worn, found 7× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Daihatsu Charade reliable?
47 Citroën Saxo Probably worse than most city cars 3,715 cars 4.3
Likely 3.0 to 5.6 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 1999 to 2003
3.6 20004.1 20014.2 20024.9 2003
Watch for: Steering rack boot damaged, found 5× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Citroën Saxo reliable?
48 Dacia Spring About average for a city car 1,835 cars 4.2
Likely 1.4 to 7.6 Yellow line: typical city car
Electric · registered 2021 to 2022
4.6 20214.0 2022
Watch for: Wheel bearing excessive play, found 45× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Dacia Spring reliable?
49 Renault Twingo Worse than most city cars 114,767 cars 4.0
Likely 2.8 to 5.3 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol, Electric, Diesel · registered 1997 to 2022
3.8 20113.5 20122.9 20133.5 20144.2 20153.6 20164.3 20175.7 20184.7 20194.4 20206.4 20215.2 2022
Watch for: Coil spring: broken, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Renault Twingo reliable?
50 Fiat Seicento Worse than most city cars 3,107 cars 3.9
Likely 2.7 to 5.3 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 1999 to 2006
3.7 20003.5 20014.6 20023.8 2003
Watch for: Footbrake: uneven across an axle, found 5× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Fiat Seicento reliable?
51 Daewoo Matiz Worse than most city cars 1,343 cars 3.5
Likely 2.3 to 4.9 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2003 to 2004
3.5 2004
Watch for: Suspension mounting area: excessively corroded, found 6× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Daewoo Matiz reliable?
52 Chevrolet Matiz Worse than most city cars 14,742 cars 3.1
Likely 2.1 to 4.3 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2005 to 2010
3.3 20053.1 20063.2 20073.0 20083.0 20092.7 2010
Watch for: Ball joint excessive play, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Chevrolet Matiz reliable?
53 Opel Adam Worse than most city cars 66,196 cars 2.8
Likely 1.9 to 4.0 Yellow line: typical city car
Petrol · registered 2013 to 2019
4.8 20133.6 20142.6 20151.9 20161.4 20171.4 20184.6 2019
Watch for: Steering rack boot damaged, found 12× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Opel Adam reliable?
All fuel types together. Ranks and verdicts compare with every city car.